# Compliance check of the delivered versions (delivery-checks.md section 7.4)

Run 2026-10-29 on v7 and carried to v8 (v8 changes only the alignment of the attribution header at 51.1 to 53.7 s, D-41; no disclaimer or restricted item is in that area); files `ice/renders/final/mohawalat-fahm-france_reel_9x16_66s_v8.mp4` (house font) and `..._66s_v8_free-font.mp4` (Almarai), against `ice/research/COMPLIANCE.md` (Status: partial). Contrast is the WCAG ratio of the text's 99.5th percentile luminance to the 40th percentile of its own box, measured on one frame per item; sizes are the CSS sizes of the build (`film/text.js`, `film/film.css`). The rules come from dated research for the user's market and platforms, not legal advice.

## Required disclaimers
| ID | Version | Present | Exact | Hold measured / required | Size measured / required | Contrast | Zone | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RD1 (the guest's analysis is attributed to him) | v8 | yes: name plate "د. عبد الكريم أمنكاي" with "أستاذ مساعد العلاقات الدولية، / معهد الدوحة للدراسات العليا" at his first appearance | wording not fixed by the rule; name and role as in the episode's own card | 11.92 to 14.24 s = 2.32 s / not stated | name 62 px Bold, role 46 px / not stated | 7.8:1 (at 13.00) | y 930 to about 1130, x 120 to 840, inside the union safe zone | PASS |
| RD1 | v8 free-font | yes, same | same | 2.32 s / not stated | same sizes in Almarai | 7.8:1 | same | PASS |
| RD2 (2022 and 2023 archive must not pass as current) | v8 | yes: "حرب أوكرانيا" over the 2022 convoy; "نفقات الجيش" over the 2023 army budget; both are the words spoken over those shots | wording not fixed by the rule | 53.90 to 55.70 = 1.80 s and 57.68 to 58.76 = 1.08 s (carried across the cut) / not stated | 132 px Regular titles / not stated | 3.9:1 on the bright convoy sky (55.00; large text), 13.3:1 (58.30) | y 870 to 1030 and 990 to 1150, inside the safe zone | PASS |
| RD2 | v8 free-font | yes, same | same | same | same sizes in Almarai | 3.9:1, 13.2:1 | same | PASS |

## Restricted claims and words (search of both versions)
| ID | Where | Timecode | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| RC1 numbers on screen not said | none: no digit appears in any on-screen text (`ice/plan/plan.json` texts) | | no hit |
| RC2 minors' faces in close-up long enough to identify | the montage shots of pupils run 4 to 14 frames each (0.16 to 0.56 s); the students' close shot was dropped for the aerial (D-35), whose faces are 30 to 50 px | 8.64 to 11.80, 24.36 to 26.64 | no hit (critic r2 fix check) |
| RC3 graphic injury images | none in the footage used | | no hit (critic r1) |
| RC4 the host's quoted line framed as his view | "فيه ناس تقول لك:" heads both plates for their whole time | 4.89 to 8.64 | no hit |
| RC5 the missile test shown as an attack or war | shown as a launch ("صاروخ باليستي", the host's "إطلاق"), dated 6 Oct 2026 in the ledger; the war footage is labelled "حرب أوكرانيا" separately | 0.00 to 4.69 | no hit |

## Not checked
- The platforms' policy pages were not fetched one by one (COMPLIANCE.md status partial): their rules for news, protest and weapons content stay NOT CHECKED beyond the general rules above.
- Political-ad rules (S6): NOT CHECKED; the reel is organic only and must not be boosted as an ad without political-ad authorization.
- Claims that need proof: CP1 (the debt figure) is not on screen; CP2 and CP3 rest on the dated sources listed in COMPLIANCE.md (S2, S5).

This is a check of the film against dated research, not legal advice.