# Critic round 5
Copy for the case-study exporter of the last check of the touched frames, `critic-09-r2.md` section "Last check"; the original stays the source.

Verdict: SHIP

## Last check
Render: sha256 5a644585...0dc53a2 (checked), 66.36 s; only 0 to 11.8 checked (evidence in `scratch/critic-r2/last/`).
- Seam at 4.00 (row 1 out 1703.72): Whisper hears "باليستي" whole in 6 of 6 passes (master and dialogue stem; whole hook, 1.9 to 4.4 and 2.6 to 5.3 windows). No guest voice before the cut: the last 80 ms (3.92 to 4.00) is unvoiced (no pitch) at -21 to -41 dB, the host's /t/ release; the first voiced frame is after the seam.
- Hook words after their sound: every word shows 3 frames after its spoken start ("ماكرون" 0.61 vs 0.45; "فيه" 4.85 vs 4.72; "الأول" 8.38 vs 8.26). Host lip sync unchanged: picture and audio offsets are both 1700.40.
- Cut at 0.40: clean (missile at 0.36, frigate at 0.40), no repeated first frame at any of the 16 cuts in 0 to 11.8. The disc swoops in at 0.52 to 0.64 with its motion blur and settles behind both heads; nothing red on either man.

Round verdict: SHIP