# Critic round 6
Copy for the case-study exporter of the marks check, `critic-09-r2.md` section "Marks check"; the original stays the source.

Verdict: SHIP

## Marks check
Render: sha256 e01599fb...dddf1d (checked), against `renders/archive/mohawalat-fahm-france_reel_9x16_master_v5-no-marks.mp4` and the official reels ZUhNxnrVuew and 1dradF-qrwI (evidence in `scratch/critic-r2/marks/`).
- Position, size and look: the bright-pixel boxes on dark studio frames are logo x 96 to 193, y 161 to 316 and wordmark x 853 to 981, y 201 to 297. ZUhNxnrVuew has the same boxes within 1 to 2 px; 1dradF-qrwI sits 5 px further left. Side by side on dark ground, strokes, weight and the red dot match.
- No box or halo: inside both boxes, away from the strokes, the corner pixels differ from the archive by 0 to 1.3 levels on dark (30.0), grey sky (1.2), bright launch sky (3.5), white montage (8.7), turn flash (32.26), blue convoy sky (54.4) and the red disc (56.8, 57.6). Accepted, as the programme does: on light ground the screen blend washes the logo and turns the dot pink, the same look as the official reel's own light frame (1dradF-qrwI at about 7.5 s). On the disc the logo reads light pink on red.
- Our text: "ماكرون" (y 366 to 450) is 45 px under the logo. "صاروخ باليستي" (ink from y 337) is 20 px under it, which is tight (P2, accept or lower T2 by 30 px). Nothing overlaps.
- Accepted, as for any fixed bug: the wordmark rides on the guest's hair when he leans right (33.2 to 33.9, 39.2 to 39.7, 58.5 to 61.5) and never covers his eyes or mouth.
- Fade: full to 63.80, then 63.88, 63.96 and 64.00 step down, gone from 64.04 as "محاولة" rises; the end card from 64.04 matches the archive (difference 0.2).
- Nothing else changed: outside the two boxes (24 px margin) the frame difference is encoding noise only (mean 1.25 per frame, at most 1.68, signed mean -0.08 to 0.10, no structure in the difference map); audio identical to the previous master (largest sample difference 0).

Round verdict: SHIP