# Critic round 1: spotify-concept-ad
Scope: the lane-grid film, draft-5 master (49.0 s), three fresh critics (A, B, C). The critics' own reports are in ice/review/round-1/.

Verdict: REVISE

## Findings
- Critic A: 1 P0, 9 P1, 8 P2
- Critic B: 1 P0, 8 P1, 6 P2
- Critic C: 1 P0, 7 P1, 7 P2
- Fixes R1-01 to R1-20 in fixes.json; the frame-0 horn fade and the end card were the blockers