# Critic round 4: spotify-concept-ad
Scope: the drawn street, the approved cut draft-14 (35.0 s), two fresh critics (the cold viewer of this round is void). The critics' own reports are in ice/review/round-4/.

Verdict: SHIP

## Findings
- Critic A (picture): SHIP, no P0 or P1, five P2 logged (off-frame sources in the first 1.25 s, two words 10 px past the 5 percent margin, the motorbike faces the other way, no motion blur on four fast moves, missing bt709 tags)
- Critic B (sound and sync): SHIP, no P0 to P2, two P3 logged (machine pulses one frame after the kick, 1.9 dB mono loss in the last second)
- First cold viewer (clarity read 3): VOID, it opened the draft by its project path and the critics' labelled packet, and no takeaway existed to match (ice/review/clarity/read-3-cold-viewer.md); the read that counts, read-3-r5 on the delivered master, ran after this round (ice/review/clarity/read-3-r5.md and its match)
- One fix applied without changing the film: bt709 colour tags on the final master (R4-01)

## Prior items
- Earlier rounds 1 to 3 judged the lane-grid world that the owner replaced (D-30)